Blake Lively, known for her close friendship with Taylor Swift, is facing criticism from fans after a private conversation between her and actor-director Justin Baldoni came to light.

The revelation has sparked debates online, with some accusing Lively of “not being a real friend” to the pop superstar.

The controversy began when Baldoni, who is directing the upcoming film adaptation of Swift’s album-inspired novel All Too Well,

shared details of his private discussion with Lively.

In the chat, Lively allegedly expressed opinions about the project that some Swifties interpreted as less than supportive. The specifics of the conversation remain unclear, but fans quickly speculated that her comments might not align with the unwavering encouragement expected from someone so publicly tied to Swift.

Social media platforms have since erupted with divided opinions. Some users have defended Lively, arguing that friends are entitled to honest opinions and private exchanges. Others, however, have labeled her actions as a betrayal, particularly given Swift’s history of loyalty and public praise for Lively.

“Blake Lively’s not being a real friend,” one user wrote on Twitter, capturing the sentiments of those disappointed by the news. Another fan added, “If your best friend can’t stand by you on something this big, who can you trust?”

Neither Lively nor Swift has commented publicly on the situation, leaving room for further speculation about the nature of their friendship. Both women have previously celebrated their bond, often sharing glimpses of their friendship through social media posts and public outings.

As the story unfolds, fans eagerly await clarification from the stars involved. For now, the incident has cast an unexpected shadow over one of Hollywood’s most high-profile friendships, leaving many to wonder whether time—and perhaps a few public statements—will mend the perceived rift.